PDA

View Full Version : PSMF = fast weight loss??? Veterans?



40 Nunc
07-21-2008, 06:51 PM
Hey all, (sorry for the long post)

Just read the thread posted by sandcracker21 regarding fast(er) weight loss. The PSMF (Protein Sparing Modified Fast) was mentioned but I couldn't find anything else on this site when searched. I Googled it and just about every article I found talked about how dangerous this type of diet can be if the proper nutrients are not taken in conjunction with the fast.

The very first article I read said to drink 4 protein shakes per day then eat a steak at night with spinich or salad w/lowfat dressing. It didn't address amount of calories, liver or kidney issues, high potential for dehydration, calcium depletion, etc.

Other articles were incredibly complicated with mathematical equations for % BF, grams carbs/pro/fat... I weigh 188 lbs and according to the calculations my daily protein requirement would be less than 90 grams???

Any veterans out there that can simplify and explain how to safely comply with this type of diet? i.e calories, protein per lbs of body weight. Amount of magnesium, calcium, potasium required... any other info?

I'm currently trying to bulk but I'd hate for someone to read the same article I did and hurt themselves by attempting a rapid weight loss with 4 shakes and a steak...

cphafner
07-21-2008, 06:54 PM
how did you search? I typed in PMSF in titles only and got over 60 results

http://wannabebigforums.com/search.php?searchid=1517520

40 Nunc
07-21-2008, 06:58 PM
I did the same. I read thru 8 or 9 articles and a couple blogs but they were either very generic or very complicated.

ryuage
07-22-2008, 12:10 AM
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com

or

http://www.amazon.com

both sites sell the book

JSully
07-22-2008, 09:15 AM
the steak has a very high fat content, therefore it would not fit in the PSMF..

its' a protein saturated modified fast.. stop and think about that for a second..

it's a modified fast, so it's going to have VERY low calories...
its protein saturated, so it's going to have high protein..

buy the book that ryuage pointed to or do a search for it on www.bodyrecomposition.com/forums ->there are a few people there that have PSMF journals you can take a look at it and see what's going on without having to buy the book..

Torrok
07-22-2008, 09:41 AM
i think its all dumb.

dont screw up your body on dumb diets.

EAT: http://whfoods.org/foodstoc.php

Guido
07-22-2008, 10:37 AM
i think its all dumb.

dont screw up your body on dumb diets.

EAT: http://whfoods.org/foodstoc.phpIt's not dumb if it works, and PSMF works well for a lot of people. if you are wanting short term quick weight loss then PSMF is the way to go. BTW, I believe that PSMF actually stands for Protein SPARING Modified Fast, in that you are cutting calories but sparing protein (keep protein high but carbs and fats lower).

For longer term sustained weight loss carb cycling is a very effective method. It involves a drastic reduction in carbs (but perhaps not quite so low as in a ketogenic diet) with planned "refeed" days wherein you are allowed to eat more carbs in order to replenish your glycogen stores (without overdoing it). A lot of people have had a lot of success on it.

40 Nunc
07-22-2008, 12:49 PM
i think its all dumb.

dont screw up your body on dumb diets.

EAT: http://whfoods.org/foodstoc.php


Like I said, I'm bulking and not looking to diet and I kind of agree with Torrok... and I appreciate the links to purchase the books but that's not why I posted this thread -

I haven't been on this site long but I've noticed that a lot of the noob's (myself included) start off looking for fast results for whatever we're trying to achieve. I've read threads where noobs argue with the veteran's over diet/workout. The veteran answers noobs questions with realistic advice and noob will argue until the veteran finally asks why noob is here in the first place.

With that in mind, a noob might think he can drop 10-15 lbs in a week if he only drinks protein shakes and eats a steak each night because he saw the same article I did and didn't research it further - not realizing how damaging it can be to the liver/kidneys or how dangerous it can be if calcium/potassium levels plummet, dehydration, etc.

I doubt many noobs will spend $39 on a diet book when they can Google "PSMF" for free... but that free information may not completely inform them and they could get hurt.

I thought that if there were some veterans that had done this type of diet they might explain a simple/safe way to include it in a routine.

ryuage
07-22-2008, 01:00 PM
hrmmm

ryuage
07-22-2008, 01:02 PM
Like I said, I'm bulking and not looking to diet and I kind of agree with Torrok... and I appreciate the links to purchase the books but that's not why I posted this thread -

I haven't been on this site long but I've noticed that a lot of the noob's (myself included) start off looking for fast results for whatever we're trying to achieve. I've read threads where noobs argue with the veteran's over diet/workout. The veteran answers noobs questions with realistic advice and noob will argue until the veteran finally asks why noob is here in the first place.

With that in mind, a noob might think he can drop 10-15 lbs in a week if he only drinks protein shakes and eats a steak each night because he saw the same article I did and didn't research it further - not realizing how damaging it can be to the liver/kidneys or how dangerous it can be if calcium/potassium levels plummet, dehydration, etc.

I doubt many noobs will spend $39 on a diet book when they can Google "PSMF" for free... but that free information may not completely inform them and they could get hurt.

I thought that if there were some veterans that had done this type of diet they might explain a simple/safe way to include it in a routine.

so what is to stop them from finding the same articles/threads as yourself and find this one... what is going to differentiate the material in what is right and wrong? there are tons of places that people can google and find the "correct" material, but how will they know? people make stupid decisions all the time and learn from them... use common sense.

JSully
07-22-2008, 01:04 PM
damn, it is sparing.. thanks guido.. I knew it was sparing for some reason put saturated.. oh well..

I'm a veteran and have used this method many times. Along with carb cycling and many other types of diet plans. It works.. regardless of being "dumb" or not.. If some kid feels like he needs to have 4 protein shakes and a steak a day then let him do it and its his fault for not researching it further when he loses all of his LBM and hates himself. 4 protein shakes per day and a steak really isn't that bad anyways. It's not PSMF but its not that bad either. To the layman, a protein shake is a MRP, be it Muscle Milk, 100% Whey Protein, or even a weight gainer. It's all a protein shake to them. So suppose this kid starts drinking 4 weight gainers and eating a steak everyday.. now he's in calorie surplus..

There's no simple/safe way to include this when you're trying to bulk.. it makes no sense unless you're going to consume 500 calories OVER your maintenance in ONLY protein.. THAT'S dumb and that's when kidney and liver issues arise.. not from 800-1200cals/day coming from only protein. PSMF is for cutting only and if someone can't figure that out, then they'll figure it out within a week of being on it.

40 Nunc
07-22-2008, 03:05 PM
Thanks LittleJake...

Again, I'm trying to gain weight not lose it so I have no intention of incorporating this into my diet/workout routine. It just sounds like a bad idea but someone new will try this diet and I figured one of the veterans could explain the process, dangers and recommend supplements, etc...



so what is to stop them from finding the same articles/threads as yourself and find this one... what is going to differentiate the material in what is right and wrong? there are tons of places that people can google and find the "correct" material, but how will they know? people make stupid decisions all the time and learn from them... use common sense.

ryuage - should we learn from stupid decisions or use common sense? Kinda hard to do both. You posted 2 links above - was that the "correct" material? This website WBB (which I found on Google) is for sharing information right? "Use common sense" could be the answer to every question posted on this site but we ask anyways hoping the "pros" (like yourself) will help us differentiate what is right and wrong...

JSully
07-22-2008, 04:56 PM
Thanks LittleJake...

Again, I'm trying to gain weight not lose it so I have no intention of incorporating this into my diet/workout routine. It just sounds like a bad idea but someone new will try this diet and I figured one of the veterans could explain the process, dangers and recommend supplements, etc...
I would recommend about 10fish oil caps, ALA (alpha lipoic acid), some kind of fat burner and a good multi-vitamin



ryuage - should we learn from stupid decisions or use common sense? Kinda hard to do both. You posted 2 links above - was that the "correct" material? This website WBB (which I found on Google) is for sharing information right? "Use common sense" could be the answer to every question posted on this site but we ask anyways hoping the "pros" (like yourself) will help us differentiate what is right and wrong...
I know I made a lot of dumb decisions before getting into nutrition. Did it hurt me? no, it just took me longer to reach my goals and made me get more involved in what I'm putting into my body. At some point, everyone will realize this.. Furthermore, the links ryuage posted:: www.bodyrecomposition.com and www.amazon.com sell the book you're referring to. www.bodyrecomposition.com is the website of the author of the PSMF aka The Rapid Fat Loss Diet and amazon.com, obviously, is a huge bookseller website where you can pickup this book.

ryuage
07-22-2008, 05:45 PM
ryuage - should we learn from stupid decisions or use common sense? Kinda hard to do both. You posted 2 links above - was that the "correct" material? This website WBB (which I found on Google) is for sharing information right? "Use common sense" could be the answer to every question posted on this site but we ask anyways hoping the "pros" (like yourself) will help us differentiate what is right and wrong...

I would imagine so... especially since the creator of the books site is in fact one of the links I posted.

hardBODmiranda
10-22-2009, 11:06 AM
Your body burns calories during digestion and when you’re eating more meals - Your body will spend more time burning calories digesting food rather than storing it as fat and a person who eats 5-to-6 small meals a day will burn much more calories than a person who eats 1-to-3 meals. Many of us don't realize that we do not need to sacrifice our love for food. I do not agree that you will need to give up food that you love to eat. The key here is to eat in moderation, my friend Christopher Guerriero once told me that I need to eat low fat longevity foods like salmon almonds, red grapes, blueberries, garlic, spinach and whole grains.

LuNa
10-22-2009, 02:37 PM
Im pretty sure your advice is a little late :).

JSully
10-23-2009, 05:04 PM
this is an old thread...

I can't believe I know so much about dieting, yet I'm such a fatass.. ugh, I just love food

angrymonkey
10-23-2009, 05:10 PM
Thanks LittleJake...

Again, I'm trying to gain weight not lose it so I have no intention of incorporating this into my diet/workout routine. It just sounds like a bad idea but someone new will try this diet and I figured one of the veterans could explain the process, dangers and recommend supplements, etc...




ryuage - should we learn from stupid decisions or use common sense? Kinda hard to do both. You posted 2 links above - was that the "correct" material? This website WBB (which I found on Google) is for sharing information right? "Use common sense" could be the answer to every question posted on this site but we ask anyways hoping the "pros" (like yourself) will help us differentiate what is right and wrong...

...and I really wish someone would lay out the diet for me so I wouldnt have to actually purchase the book.


Gotcha.

ryuage
10-26-2009, 06:12 PM
;) heh

Mercuryblade
10-28-2009, 01:38 PM
Your body burns calories during digestion and when you’re eating more meals - Your body will spend more time burning calories digesting food rather than storing it as fat and a person who eats 5-to-6 small meals a day will burn much more calories than a person who eats 1-to-3 meals. Many of us don't realize that we do not need to sacrifice our love for food. I do not agree that you will need to give up food that you love to eat. The key here is to eat in moderation, my friend Christopher Guerriero once told me that I need to eat low fat longevity foods like salmon almonds, red grapes, blueberries, garlic, spinach and whole grains.

Nothing quite like some low-fat salmon and almonds.

SEOINAGE
10-28-2009, 06:45 PM
Nothing quite like some low-fat salmon and almonds.

I laughed at that one too.

alexei1lee
07-27-2010, 03:30 AM
I expect you will put more article related to this.