View Full Version : Eating clean?!? Can you critique?

11-18-2003, 11:24 AM
I've been reading these forums for a while, and everyone keeps saying that you have to eat clean in order to lose weight. I just wanted to know what constitutes eating clean? Or maybe someone can tell me what is eating dirty?

Considering I eliminate obvious pitfalls like high simple carb foods like sugary drinks (never drink it anyway), what does the rest consist of?

My stats are: 5'11", 179lbs, 17%bf, 23 years old
My diet is usually:

7:30 : Kashi go lean cereal (high fiber cereal, no sugar), 1 cup milk

10:30 : 2 egg yolks, 4 eggwhites omelette with 3 strips of bacon that have the fat cut off, and only meat and trace fat left. I also continuously drain any melted fat while panfrying. Also have 2 slices of WW bread.

12:30 : 2 90% lean sirloin beef patties with 2 slices WW bread, sometimes veggies are thrown in or I'll have chicken or fish instead

2:00pm : lettuce and baby carrots raw to snack on, or a banana

6:00pm : <gym>

7:00pm: GNC 100% Protein shake, 2 scoops 40g protein

8:00pm: 1 serving chicken/fish/lamb and some veggies stirfried with some spices and soya sauce, little canola oil used.

10:00pm: Small serving of cottage cheese or nuts + multivitamin + fish oil cap.

I snack on pecans/almonds or peanuts if I get the munchies.

I'm wondering if this is a cutting diet or a bulking diet...I seem to be eating more food than ever in my life, but what defines a cutting or bulking? Is it just the calories above or below maintenance or the quality/quantity of food?

Should I be eating something that will benefit cutting but not bulking etc...I'm really confused about it.

I work out 5 days a week Mon-Fri 2 days cardio, different body part each day, heavy lifting. My pulse is usually racing from lifting, and I'm sweating before even hitting the cardio.

Appreciate your help. I'm trying to get lean and muscular and am planning on going on a cutting diet for a month or 2 before moving to a bulking. I've had a belly and "love handles" all my life, but dont look fat in clothes. Help me get lean... .I'll do anything!!!

11-18-2003, 11:48 AM
Yeah man, that's a pretty clean diet you've got.

Bulking/cutting relates to the quantity of calories you're taking in. The foods can all be the same, just alter the quantities.

11-18-2003, 11:56 AM
Hmm, so I wonder if I'm on a bulking (eating too much) or cutting diet.

Just to know what to avoid, what is not eating clean? Is that just not breaking up your meals into smaller ones, and or stuffing yourself silly?

I want to get my weight to about 170 lbs....that's 9-10 lbs I intend on losing. Is losing a pound every 2 weeks a good goal or, should that be a pound every week? I have muscle, I just have a lot of subcutaneous fat as well, so ideally I dont want to lose the muscle that I do have (hence the high protein diet and weightlifting).

11-18-2003, 12:02 PM
Not eating clean would be eating crap like fast food, empty calories like sweets etc.

What makes a diet bulking or cutting is just whether you gain or lose weight with it respectively. You could go on a clean bulk and eat healthy foods with the fat coming from good sources like EFAs, nuts, fish and oils, and minimise the amount of fat you gain by gaining at a slow and steady rate, or you could bulk in a non clean fashion by eating everything in sight :p

Try eating that much food for a week and see if you lose or gain weight or stay the same. Then adjust the calories accordingly until you're losing. Half a pound a week is a good target to minimise muscle loss.