Cals/Carb Question - Need it for friend

[Ðragons]

i got asked today at work, and i know i asked before and didnt get a propper answer :P

so iff anyone knows for example if.

u consumed.

1800 cals, 150g carbs

or

1800 cals, 50g carbs

would u still lose the same ammount of weight?

thx

[Vido]

Most likely, but if the extra carbs forced you to consume an inadequate amount of protein then you might end up losing more muscle than fat in that case.

In addition, eating only 50g carbs/day will cause a bigger initial drop in water weight, which isn't really important once you carb back up, but it should still be noted.