PDA

View Full Version : Effects of Cheat Meals Compared to Cheat Day?



Chubrock
03-19-2006, 10:01 PM
Got to thinking about Cheat Meals/Cheat Days and figured I'd pose this question to some of the more nutrition suave people on these forums. Now I know calories in and out are going to determine weight gained, but this isn't what the question is about. What different effects with regards to the body do you see in taking Cheat Meals as opposed to a Cheat Day? I guess I should define the two a little better. When I say Cheat Day, I'm referring to the Cheat Days some people have where they cram 7000 calories of sweets and what not into one day. When I talk about Cheat Meals, I mean eating say a semi bad dinner on Friday night, and then eating clean throughout the weekend except for one meal on Saturday and one on Sunday. For comparison's sake, lets say you ate the exact same amount of bad **** during both the Cheat Meal and Cheat Day scenarios. Which do you think would have the most adverse reaction within the body? I probably worded this really bad, but I'm tired and don't feel like thinking my way through all this.

Holto
03-19-2006, 10:41 PM
I know calories in and out are going to determine weight gained

Just usage of the word gained makes me want to ask:

Are you bulking?

If you are cutting I would do a cheat day VS a cheat meal Fri,Sat,Sun. The cheat day would give the benefits of a refeed with roughly the same in cals.

BostonBull
03-20-2006, 03:55 AM
I consider a cheat day and day I go over my Maintanance calories by 500 or more. SO if you are having some crappy meal 3 times a week and completely blowing your daily needs to ****e then I would say its a cheat DAY. Now if your bulkig then I guess theres really no reason to worry.

Anthony
03-20-2006, 05:24 AM
Come up with a plan. Follow it 90% of the time. Problem solved.

HILL
03-20-2006, 05:58 AM
If i can get my head round what your saying weight wise i think its all going to be the same. the more i read up on this and the more i see on here my opinion is its all based on weekly outgoings and incomings as much as anything else so wether you have it all in one day or spread over 3 meals over 3 days the total cals for the week will be the same.

Advantages from spreading it out over 3 days is obviously depending on what you eat you will have the nebefits especially while cutting of extra energy for workouts the bad thing is you going to be bloated and taking in empty cals for 3 days effecting protein.

Advantages of having it in one day is itsa more controlable and is not effecting you diet for the rest of the week however i always feel like **** after having a complete cheat day but thats just me.

Their is however far to many factors to be able to give astraight answere. Such as are you bulking or cutting/ what will your cheat meals contain etc etc etc

hope this helps

Chubrock
03-20-2006, 07:07 AM
Oh the Super Midget, I mean Moderator coming up with supreme judgement haha. The question was just a more in general type thing, though I should have said it was geared more to those cutting. I was just wondering that if a single day as a refeed is used to affect different hormones, compounds and what not in the body, what would be the effect if instead of one day, you spread the refeed over 2 or three days. Of course if you spread it over the 2 or 3 days, you'd feel the empty spaces with good, clean food, but overall, would it have the same effect as if you just did a single day of refeeding? BTW this is nothing I'm looking at really doing for myself persay, just was interested in the whole idea.

Holto
03-20-2006, 10:22 AM
I was just wondering that if a single day as a refeed is used to affect different hormones, compounds and what not in the body, what would be the effect if instead of one day, you spread the refeed over 2 or three days.

I'm pretty sure that you will get more benefits in terms of leptin with a cheat day. I also suspect that you will get better glycogen storage with a cheat day but that may simply come down to mathematics.