Looks like its not over yet........(sigh)
Looks like its not over yet........(sigh)
Good grief, just when I thought there might be some closure.
who cares! the money went to cartwright and wenning. hoff was suspended! who cares what is said after the fact. it's over, let it go. nobody needs closure. i still like lou regardless of his view on the situation.
So many people seem so sure over whether there was cheating or not. On one hand, apparently nobody saw it in person. Which is very important because if it were that obvious somebody would likely have seen something. On the other hand, the video makes it seem clearly like there was cheating. I think if you have to go with one or the other, you go with what you saw in person. That doesn't mean that cheating did or did not happen, just that you have to go with what was seen in person by people looking from 30 different angles instead of what you see on the video from one. We may never know what happened for CERTAIN, just what the evidence leads us to believe is likely. In the end, I sort of agree with Louie. Not that Hoff was CERTAINLY innocent, just that you have to go with the judgment on the platform.
It just seems like a very odd statement from Louie.
So does anyone have any doubts now about why no one said anything to Louie at the meet?
I said this over on Outlaws and I'll say it here and then I'm done with it:
If it's not true then why did I get calls from people at the meet and after the meet saying wait until you see the s**t Hoff pulled? The suspension and money being changed happened for a reason. I respect the hell out of Louie and appreciate all he has done for the sport, but I am not going to sit back and just take his word on this one.
Either way this s**t is over with. Hoff will be watched like a hawk everytime he lifts. This incident will probably have judges everywhere more on their toes. I'm done with this drama now, it's time to worry about my own training.
I say this fully knowing there are guys here with close ties to Westside. These words do not reflect my opinion of them
there may be some repercussions for Hoff at westside that Lou doesn't want to make public. Maybe Louie doesn't want to publicly talk crap about one of his guys at westside. That does sound weird for Lou though.
This is what strikes me as odd
" have already given Matt Wenning and extra $500 which gave him the second place money and Scott Cartwright $1,000 which moved him into third place. "
If he is so innocent, why did Louie pay up?
well, this doesnt make a whole lot of sense to me. If thats WSB's official stance on it, then its there stance. I just dont understand why, lifts were discounted, money exchanged, places changed, punishments handed out, if their was nothing wrong.....seems odd to do all that, and then come out and say thier was no cheating...
[/QUOTE]I say this fully knowing there are guys here with close ties to Westside. These words do not reflect my opinion of them[/QUOTE]
I like this part Vinnie, I think I will start placing disclaimers in my posts as well lol
I still don't see why no one said anything to anyone about it. If they saw something, they should have spoken up. I was sitting in the front row during his benches and I couldn't see anything, Lou was right next to me and didn't mention anything either. Someone that said they saw something, or noticed an abnormal bulge should have said something to a ref, or Jesse, or Mike Ferguson. That would cut out the whole factor of the internet
true lones, if anyone saw anything at the meet they should have said something. But they didnt say anything, so we get a vid to look at....
To answer that question though, do you get up and watch over the top of other lifters when you are competing? I dont. I sit in my chair and watch from afar, but much like the audience, you cant see anything, but maybe the bar move.
One other thing is that their are wayyy to many spotters involved in the lift. This is something that I have told jesse in the past. I dont like the fact that there are 3 spotters on each side of the bar and the handoff guy is allowed to stay on the platform....its just too much. Its not lifter friendly, its not spectator friendly, its not judge friendly, its just too much. I understand jesse's stance..he wants the lifter to be safe, but its too much. If two or three good spotters cant handle 800+, then you dont have the right spotters. The only angle that anyone can really see from is the one that was shot at this meet.....
Just my opinion, I still have the same stance as I did before, I still respect the fact that everyone is allowed to have their own opinion of it
It still doesn't change the fact that several people said they saw something under Hoff's shirt at the meet. If they thought it was that out of line (and it was, if its true) they should have said something at the meet right when they saw it, or immediately after. It doesn't make sense to me...
The ONLY federation here is an IPF affiliate. The rules clearly state that drug use is prohibitted. At the same time many of the top local lifters brag about their drug use. Why doesn't anyone say anything? Two reasons and I bet money they applied here too:
1) No one wants to be seen as a cry baby or rat.
2) Usually people will be afraid that even if they do tell, the guy cheating is in with the authorities running the meet or federation so nothing will happen.
After seeing this public statement. I am more confident than ever that anyone who saw anything weird just said to themselves: "Screw it, nothing will happen anyway."
Soooo...... Louie's implying the video was doctored?
I assume thiers more than one video right? What about the eyewitnesses (after the fact no less!)
I have not spoken to Louie about this. I probably won't unless he brings it up.
My take is that he did what he did with the money to try to appease everyone and move on. Louie respects those who do, not those who talk. I think he sees the anonymous people on the net who trash every lift of the best of the best for what it is, those who weren't there trying to judge something after the fact and being negative for the sake of being negative.
Read what he wrote carefully. He collects big money for these meets. He spends a LOT of his own money. His invests time AND money and what does he get for it but a bunch of whining and complaining from those who were not there? I can understand his frustration.
I remember a WPO meet (at the Arnold) where Louie, Doris, and myself were the only ones awarding cash in fist (or a couple of checks as well as cash in my case). Louie made SURE those lifters were actually going to get some money. THAT is the kind of guy he is. He does more for people than most of you will ever know. THAT is the kind of guy he is. He does what he does for the love of the sport.
Like I said before, nothing was noted at the meet. You cannot go back in time, therefore you cannot conclusively prove anything. People are damning Hoff without knowing for sure. They want to convict him on hearsay. That is stupid and dangerous.
At any meets in the future Hoff will be watched closely. That is all that should come of this.
I respect Louie and am glad he has spoken his peace on the matter.
I would say it is highly likely Lou hasnt watched the vid and prolly wont.....I am sure he heard about it from others. Just my thought on that.
My question is should everything count that we can get by the judges? I can set a WR in a meet tomorrow, if I go to a 3 brd with it...no camera allowed lol
Not questioning anyones integrity or attacking Lou, WSB or any others that may have an opposing view....
IF video were allowed as part of the judging process as a meet rule prior to its commencement, then it should be considered. If not, then everyone should go with the calls made at the meet. That's it.
I don't like someone lying and telling me that something was white when you can clearly see that it's black. And that is what Louie is doing.
Well spoken... As you stated, things do get missed, and life does go on.
Besides, I'm sure Hoffs a good kid. He's only (21) for christ sake... I made a lot wrose mistakes at his age!
He'll learn from this incident and come back better for it!
Just my 2-cent