that looks like sadomasochistic pornography, lol. just do some shrugs
I'd agree and go with the shrugs but if you're set on it- go with what's comfortable and what's cheapest (prioritise in that order )
I got mine for I think 10 bucks. It's nylon material. Favorite piece of equipment I've purchased. I use it once a week.
If you're under 220lbs that's not something you should even consider worrying about.
Try deadlifting instead.