Has anyone ever figured this out and which is actually cheaper? I've been using homemade ones from that shake recipe thread and they definitely do become expensive. Milk, Natty PB, Olive Oil, Whey, etc. I'm starting think maybe brand name weightgainer products might be cheaper...or am I wrong? I'd think buying a big ass tub of weightgainer product(like the new Maximus by AtLarge) and put enough of it for 1000 calories in milk would be cheaper and easier. I'm a fixed income, so whatever is cheaper is essential for me. On the other hand, with a homemade one you know exactly what's in them.
What's the final say on this?