PDA

View Full Version : A general question about cutting



SpecialK
01-31-2005, 06:08 PM
Would this be a good cutting strategy:

Reduce daily intake of cals by 200 each week until I start to notice/measure fat loss, then remain at that level or even add 200 back to make sure I'm not taking out too much. While doing this, I would keep my current 50/20/30 c/f/p ratio.

Also for my next question: Is cardio necessary for cutting? It seems to me that you have 2 choices when cutting: reduce the amount of calories you are consuming, increase the amount you are burning, or a combination of the two. Is that correct? Can I get by without cardio if I reduce my calories by a sufficient amount? The reason I say that is because I am currently eating 5k cals per day, and I always feel stuffed. It wouldn't hurt me to cut down to even 4k per day. Is the main reason people do cardio when cutting is so they can eat slightly more and don't have to feel hungry all day?

Double D
01-31-2005, 06:16 PM
If you want to lose weight and cut all you have to do is burn more calories than you takin in during the day. The less you take in the easier it will be to create this deficit and the more weight you will lose, however as you start to lose weight quickly along with that goes muscle. I would recommend when cutting cals to cut carbs, not protein and fat. Keep protein high as this will help to maintain muscle during the cut. Cut fat as you progress during the cut, but not too low.
As for the cardio it will definantly make it easier to cut, especially as the cut goes on. In the beginning you will find it easy to lose without cardio but as you get leaner it will be tougher, so i would recommend doing cardio and increase the amount as you go on.
Theres several different methods out there for cutting. 2 of the most popular on this board seem to be the "UD2" and "PSMF". Lots of people on this site seem to use both, but they are pretty hard core, and it depends on how serious you are.

Vido
01-31-2005, 07:21 PM
Would this be a good cutting strategy:

Reduce daily intake of cals by 200 each week until I start to notice/measure fat loss, then remain at that level or even add 200 back to make sure I'm not taking out too much. While doing this, I would keep my current 50/20/30 c/f/p ratio.

You won't be losing any muscle doing that, but you might be cutting for 3 years...


Is the main reason people do cardio when cutting is so they can eat slightly more and don't have to feel hungry all day?

I would say yes, but cardio also has other benefits as well, most notably increased nutrient partitioning effects.

SpecialK
01-31-2005, 08:47 PM
You won't be losing any muscle doing that, but you might be cutting for 3 years...



I would say yes, but cardio also has other benefits as well, most notably increased nutrient partitioning effects.

First let me add that I don't need to lose a ton of fat. I'd estimate my bf% is in the 12-13% range. I want to get down into the single digit range so I can see my abs again w/o flexing ;)

Having said that, why would it take me 3 years using my strategy? I searched through some cutting threads and noticed that people were recommending dropping no more than 200-300 cals/day per week.

Vido
01-31-2005, 10:37 PM
Having said that, why would it take me 3 years using my strategy? I searched through some cutting threads and noticed that people were recommending dropping no more than 200-300 cals/day per week.

That's to ensure ZERO muscle loss. Personally, I'd rather lose a lb or two of muscle if it meant I could cut infinitely quicker.

I used to agree with the people saying that, but have changed my stance. I now believe that if you're not going to do a "hardcore" cut (UD2, PSMF, etc.) you shouldn't even bother. A properly done UD2 should also lead to zero muscle loss, and potentially even slight gains. PSMF won't hold on to the lean mass as well, but nothing strips the fat off more quickly.

SpecialK
02-01-2005, 12:11 AM
Well, if I follow my plan, then after 5 weeks, I will be down to 4k cals. I can't imagine that I would have to drop much lower than that to see any results. I could be wrong, of course. I'll look into the UD2.

Vido
02-01-2005, 12:27 AM
Well, if I follow my plan, then after 5 weeks, I will be down to 4k cals. I can't imagine that I would have to drop much lower than that to see any results. I could be wrong, of course. I'll look into the UD2.

You might be right, but to me that 5 weeks is just wasted time. You could probably be DONE your cut by then if you did something more drastic.

Manveet
02-01-2005, 09:41 AM
First let me add that I don't need to lose a ton of fat. I'd estimate my bf% is in the 12-13% range. I want to get down into the single digit range so I can see my abs again w/o flexing ;)

Having said that, why would it take me 3 years using my strategy? I searched through some cutting threads and noticed that people were recommending dropping no more than 200-300 cals/day per week.

If you are at 12-13%, definately give UD2.0 a try. You will probably see a lot more progress with an 8 week cycle of UD2.0, then just merely cutting 200 cals a week (btw, I have tried that approach before, and I still lost some muscle mass)